Thanksgiving Pre-Orders

Want to guarantee that you get the goodies you’re looking for? Need to impress your parents in law? Pre-order Your Thanksgiving treats today!

Sweetly, Sammy will be carrying on our Thanksgiving tradition of dropping the best pies and cheesecakes in town. Pre-orders begin in November 2! Make sure that you order yours now before they run out. Pick up dates will be November 25 or November 26. See further instructions below.

All pies: 9”, serve 12-14 people | All cheesecakes 10”, serve 16-18 people

Pick -up Instructions

Dates: Nov 25 or Nov 26

Time: Nov 25: 9am-5pm | Nov 26: 6pm-9pm

Location: Check your email!

  • A confirmation email will be sent to you regarding your order with the pickup address and an affirmation of your preferred pickup date and time.

How to pick up:

  • Upon arrival, call (407)720-9097

  • Give one of the Sweetly, Sammy team the name you used on your order. We will bring it right out to your car!

  • Take your goodies and enjoy!

Apple Cinnamon Pie
$45.00

The perfect Granny Smith apple pie with bourbon and brown sugar caramel, flaky piecrust, a toasted oat crumble, and cinnamon whipped cream.

FL Key Lime Pie
$45.00

Because in Florida, we eat Keylime pie year-round! This pie has a graham cracker crust with a Keylime curd filling and a meringue topping. The perfect dish to brighten up any Thanksgiving dessert table.

Banana Cream Caramel Pie
$45.00

A jazzy version of your grandma’s banana cream pie. Traditional banana and vanilla-bean pastry cream custard with fresh bananas, dulce de leche caramel, and cinnamon whipped cream.

French Silk Cheesecake
$55.00

The ultimate chocolate cheesecake with a silky, milk chocolate filling, chocolate cookie crust, and white chocolate whipped ganache, topped with chocolate shavings.

Bourbon Pecan Pie
$45.00

Possibly the most classic Thanksgiving pie… But with bourbon! This toasted pecan pie has a bourbon molasses filling, and a flake, vanilla piecrust, topped with cinnamon and maple whipped cream.

Biscoff Caramel Cheesecake
$55.00

This cookie butter and vanilla cheesecake is topped with dulce de leche caramel, toasted pecans, caramel cookie crumbles, and a chocolate whipped ganache.

Lemon Blackberry Cheesecake
$55.00

This cheesecake will brighten up any Thanksgiving dessert table! With a velvety lemon cheesecake, and a blackberry jam swirl, it is topped off with a lemon whipped ganache and a vanilla cream with fresh blackberries.

Pumpkin Spice Cheesecake
$55.00

Think pumpkin pie but even better! This pumpkin spice cheesecake is silky and beautiful with a graham cracker crust and cinnamon whipped cream with a Vietnamese cinnamon sprinkle.

Why wait?

“You are stunning, Darling, and you deserve some Fall Goodies!”